Skip to Content

Is Magic the Gathering the hardest game?

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

Have you ever wondered if Magic the Gathering is a difficult game to play? Anyone interested in the MTG gameplay can learn the game very easily

After diving into the basic rules with a few practice games, you’ll gain confidence to build strategy. It all starts with a beginner sampling a Welcome deck, before advancing into making a custom deck. 

Is Magic the Gathering the hardest game? Yes, Magic the Gathering is a hard game based on cerebral exercise. 

It is even so difficult and complex that computers are not able to figure out the implications of the game theory. As a result, algorithms have been able to determine how a game is played and the outcome between players. 

Magic the Gathering is designed such that it’s easy to get into but very difficult to master the game. 

On the one hand, a player finds it easier to cast the creatures and throw them to the opponent. But at the same time, a player experiences difficulty in interacting with the stack, timing the ability of activation, mastering the sideboard, to spell and drop the lands, which are very instrumental activities in the MTG game.

MTG game is very intimidating, especially for beginners, since it has over 200 pages of the rulebook that a player needs to understand. 

In addition, the game has over 20000 unique cards, which a player needs to familiarize with when it comes time to buy the magic cards for their collection. 

However, this trading card game is quite approachable and very affordable to get started with. Depending mainly on the player’s goals and objective for joining the game, the cost of entrance can vary widely.

Is Magic The Gathering the hardest game in the world?

Yes, Magic the Gathering is the hardest game in the world. In fact, the new proof shows that MTG is now the world’s most complex game with all the levels of intricacies involved. 

In an MTG game, two or more players can play the game, where each player assembles a collection of 60 cards from a pool of over 20000 cards created purposely for this game. 

These 60-card sets chosen by a player have varying powers. This trading card game has the same role-playing integrations as Dungeons and Dragons. 

However, MTG has more cards in the collection with complex rules for a player to master than any other card game in the world.

When it comes to computerizing the game, an independent researcher known as Alex Churchill of the board game designer department in Cambridge shows that MTG is the most complex real-world game to compute in terms of encoding the game rules in a Turing machine. 

Determining the winning strategy of a player in the MTG game on a computer is equivalent to a problem in computer programming called a halting problem. 

This halting problem of the MTG game makes it difficult for the program with certain input to finish running on a computer because the problem is non-computable. 

Therefore, no algorithmic coding can assist in determining the winner of the MTG game on a computer.

Mastering the MTG game is a very hard task, especially when performing instrumental moves in the game. Such moves include mastery of the stack, timing ability of the player on activation of cards, mastering the sideboard, and spelling and dropping the lands.

Is MTG more complex than chess?

Yes, Magic the Gathering is more complex than chess. The complexity of a game is determined by whether it is computable or not. 

According to computer scientists, chess is more complicated when it comes to determining its algorithms codes in the computer, but chess indeed is computable. Therefore, its algorithm can be solved. 

However, even having resources to solve chess algorithms, computer scientists have found it difficult to develop its solution. Nonetheless, the complexity of chess has some limits basing on the number of boards and pieces played in the world.

On the other hand, determining the winning strategy of a player in MTG is the most complex activity in the world of computer science because of the halting problem. 

This issue makes the MTG game not finish running an algorithm on a computer. Also, some cards in the MTG game require the real input of a player, such as naming the card and determining whether or not to take any action during the game, which makes things even more complicated. 

The main goal of computer scientists was to load the game on the computer with no more programs, which led to the elimination of such cards in the game that is against the rules of the game. 

This makes MTG the most complex game globally and non-computable since there is no algorithm for the game, unlike chess, which is computable. 

Why is Magic so complicated?

Magic is very complicated trading card game. In fact, there are several non-trivial choices that an MTG player must make in the gameplay.

This choices include the naming of the cards, determining to take any action or not and spelling of the lands. An algorithm is not in a position to determine the perfect strategy a player needs to win. 

In this regard, MTG becomes the most complicated non-trivial game globally compared to others such as Jenga, Uno and Monopoly.

How do you make Magic the Gathering easier to play?

As we all know by now, Magic the Gathering is very complex and difficult card game. Though it can be beginner friendly, the game is challenging to master with many intricacies included over the 20,000+ available cards. 

In order to make MTG easier to play, start by planning on how to win a game. This is essential to ease the game, especially in decision-making on the moves a player takes. 

For instance, a player must plan to release aggressive creatures before the opponent cast powerful cards. 

Have a winning mindset and not a “losing.” Unless on a basic level, a player should not play to avoid loss but rather to win. 

For instance, before a player makes a defensive move, the aim should not be preventing the opponent from winning, but rather to assist the player to win.

Play around with cards that are beatable. Identify the cards that can’t be beaten no matter the move and play as if those cards don’t exist.

Focus on the overall decisions, not the initial result. Do not decide whether a decision made is correct or not by the initial result and not focus on uncontrollable things.

Consider what the opponent thinks. For any move an opponent makes, think why the opponent made such a move before making a counter move.

Utilize MTG content and read through all available literature to gain knowledge on the rules and techniques of advanced gameplay.

Find the optimal line to focus more on a winning approach. Therefore, practice and practice more until mastery of the game technique is undoubted.

Is Magic the Gathering difficult

Why Magic the Gathering is Hard: Conclusion 

Magic the Gathering is the most complex, non-computable, and non-trivial card game globally because algorithms fail to determine the winning strategy of a player.

It is known as the most difficult game in the world and incomparably complex when mashed against chess. 

The reason why MTG is complicated is because the game requires making decisions of naming the card, determining any action, and spelling the lands ,which algorithms cannot be input the different variations to win.

For any beginner, making MTG game easy to play is possible. Simply, make a plan to strategize winning scenario and select aggressive cards before the opponent player uses powerful spells.

Also, select cards that are beatable and understand each cards potential usage. Review Magic the Gathering content regarding basic rules and techniques to help you enjoy the game to the maximum.

The more you practice and learn from winning and losing, the better you get at this game. Though it may seem complex and extremely hard to play, it is possible for beginners to have fun and learn new skills with each round that passes.